Competition Among T&E Co-Brand & Bank Proprietary Cards Heats Up
Navigator Edition: October / November 2017
By: David Woynerowski, Andrew Broadhead, and Peter Lischick
Travel and entertainment (T&E) co-brand credit cards (co-brands) are facing more competition than ever from bank proprietary travel and cash-back rewards cards. In the past, bank proprietary travel rewards cards were designed to mimic airline cards, but in recent years, banks have invested in features that make their cards superior in many respects, and more threatening, to T&E co-brands. Moreover, the competitive landscape for T&E co-brands has intensified as new entrants (e.g., regional banks) and established players expand their product suites and inundate the U.S. credit card market with a variety of new bank travel and cash-back products – Figure 1 shows at least 22 new bank rewards products in the last 19 months.
This proliferation of proprietary rewards products is likely the result of an extended period of historically high profitability in the credit card industry, a general flight to quality, and efforts to attract previously credit-averse emerging affluent segments (e.g., Millennials). Recent market disruption caused by loyalty program changes at the major airlines may have inadvertently made T&E co-brands more vulnerable to these new or improved bank products. Key areas of investment by banks include:
- Enhanced Earn Rates: Banks have adopted a broader set of spend categories that qualify for higher earn rates and launched products with high baseline earn rates.
– The PNC Cash Rewards card offers cardholders an expansive set of cash-back spend categories: 4% on gas, 3% on dining, and 2% on grocery purchases
– The Santander Ultimate Cash Back card offers cardholders a high baseline earn rate with unlimited 1.5% cash-back regardless of spend category
– The US Bank Altitude Reserve card offers a 50% bonus for travel redemptions
– Barclaycard CashForward allows cardholders to receive 5% cash-back for every redemption
- Alternative Travel Benefits: Banks have invested in partnerships and enhanced existing travel benefits in order to address legacy gaps relative to T&E co-brands.
– The Capital One Quicksilver* and American Express Platinum cards partnered with Uber to offer discounts or credits for rides
– American Express partnered with Hilton and SPG to offer status in their respective loyalty programs to Platinum cardholders
– American Express launched Centurion Lounges at select airports across the U.S. and added access to the lounges as a benefit for the American Express Platinum card
- Flexibility/Ease of Redemption: To fortify a core pillar of the value proposition for bank proprietary rewards programs, banks lowered the friction of redemption by offering more options and the ability to redeem rewards via mobile devices.
– Most major banks have established a partnership with Amazon to offer Pay with Points functionality
– US Bank made mobile real-time rewards redemption a key selling point of their new Altitude Reserve credit card
T&E providers (e.g., airlines, hotels) have also invested during this period, although with a greater focus on enhancing the utility of their underlying rewards programs (which can affect the perceived value of the linked co-brand card). Specific areas of investment by T&E providers include:
- Expanded Loyalty Partnerships: T&E providers established partnerships to offer new earn opportunities to their member bases and/or seek reciprocal status for their elite members.
– United and Marriott offer reciprocal earn opportunities and certain elite members receive comparable status matching
– Airlines have partnered with hotels and car rental companies to allow members to earn miles on hotel stays and car rentals
- Loyalty Status Enhancements: Cardholders are offered elite status or waivers for certain qualification requirements.
– Hilton Honor Surpass cardholders automatically receive Honor Gold status
– Cathay Pacific cardholders receive complimentary green tier membership for one year to the Marco Polo Club, Cathay’s loyalty program
- Spend-Threshold Rewards: Cardholders receive enhanced benefits for meeting certain spend thresholds.
– Hilton Honors Card from American Express upgrades cardholders to Gold Status from Silver after they spend $20,000 in a year
– American Airlines offers certain cardholders (AAdvantage Executive Card and Aviator Silver) elite qualifying miles for meeting certain spend thresholds
On balance, banks have leveled the rewards playing field between their proprietary credit cards and T&E co-brands. Accenture recently compared the features and benefits of the leading U.S. bank proprietary travel and cash-back cards with those of the largest T&E co-brands, as well as a number of regional banks and smaller T&E co-brand programs that recently launched new products. Figure 2 highlights the key areas of differentiation between T&E co-brand and bank proprietary travel and cash-back programs and summarizes the prevalence of credit card capabilities across the two segments.
Figure 2: Prevelance of U.S. Travel and Cash-back Credit Card Features & Benefits
Source: company websites and Accenture analysis.
1 In most cases, experiential rewards offered on co-brand travel cards are supplied by the issuer of the co-brand travel card. There are a few T&E providers that offer their own experiential rewards (e.g. Disney offers the “Character Experience” exclusively for cardholders to take photos with Disney characters). 2 Spend requirements to achieve acquisition bonuses were not included in this metric. 3 In-flight discounts, free internet, Uber credits, etc. 4 Bonus earn rate categories does not include “on us” earn rate categories. 5 This metric measures how common it is for cardholders to be granted status for being a cardholder, whether certain requirements for achieving status are waived (e.g., purchase requirements), or whether the issuer / co-brand partner offered enhanced rewards to compensate cardholders for their loyalty (e.g., Wells Fargo Propel Amex cardholders earn a 10% annual bonus in reward points for maintaining a checking or savings account). 6 This capability measures the number of ways that miles / points can be redeemed (e.g., statement credit, car rentals, gift cards, etc.). 7 For certain T&E providers point pooling may be limited to people that live at the same address or family members.
Although T&E providers still hold advantages in certain areas, bank proprietary travel and cash-back cards are differentiating beyond more flexible reward redemption through higher base earn rates, bonus earn rate categories, and mobile rewards redemption.
Two of the largest airlines have responded with new product launches recently. United and Delta introduced products that both appear to target less frequent flyers with different approaches. The new products offer straight-forward rewards with compelling earn rates while stripping away traditional features (including travel perks and annual fees) of T&E co-brands that are less valued by these customers. However, Delta’s product, in offering SkyMiles as the rewards currency, is an entry-level product for the credit card and frequent flyer program. In contrast, United’s TravelBank card appears more focused on addressing the cash-back segment, as it offers TravelBank cash instead of miles as the rewards currency. While it will take time to determine whether these products succeed in growing the airlines’ card portfolios, Delta and United have opened new competitive fronts with bank proprietary cards.
Looking forward, it will be interesting to see how other T&E providers respond to the proprietary bank rewards card threat.
*Uber’s and Capital One Quicksilver’s partnership is no longer offered.
For more information, please contact David Woynerowski, Managing Director, at firstname.lastname@example.org, Andrew Broadhead, Manager, at email@example.com, or Peter Lischick, Consultant, at firstname.lastname@example.org.
To read the rest of this article, please subscribe to