Six Months after Interchange Regulation in the EU: How Have Card Products Changed?
First Annapolis has been closely monitoring the product offerings of the top issuers in several European markets in order to gauge issuers’ reactions to the interchange decreases that went into effect in December 2015 (see Figure 1). Issuers’ immediate responses to reduced interchange revenues (as observed in January 2016) included rationalizing their product set, reducing rewards, and increasing APRs and annual fees, and we predicted that issuers and co-brand partners would continue optimizing their rewards programs and narrowing the customer value proposition of rewards to specific segments such as supermarkets, petrol, and travel in the short-term. Our latest research, covering activity from January through July 2016, confirms our initial hypothesis: issuers continue to rationalize their product set, reduce rewards value, and rely more on fees to drive product revenues.
Annual Fees and APRs
Annual fees (see Figures 1 and 2) have continued to increase since January. In Spain, Portugal, France, and Italy, almost half of the top five to six issuers have raised their annual card fees. In France, Credit Mutuel and BNP Paribas have increased annual fees on cards by 2% on average. In Spain, the average increase was as high as 26% (Caixa Bank and Banco Popular) for cards that saw an upwards price adjustment. In Germany, where interchange hit hard on credit cards (see Figure 3), several large, well known issuers are now charging on average 20% more for some of their card offerings than they did in the beginning of 2016. Additionally, one of the largest banks in the Netherlands has increased fees on some of its credit cards by 60%.
Figure 2: Card Modifications Six Months After the Interchange Regulation
(n=76; % of researched issuers)
Figure 3: Effective Interchange Rates by European Market
(selected European markets)
Note: Interchange regulation is not currently enforced in Norway, and its local debit scheme operates with no interchange.
Source: First Annapolis Consulting European card product research, company websites.
Issuers have also continued increasing credit card APRs since January (see Figure 1 and 2) to compensate for the revenue lost from interchange regulation. Markets where most issuers have increased their APRs include Portugal, Poland, and Italy, where rates have increased by 30 bps, 100 bps, and 131 bps, respectively.
Loyalty and Co-Brand Rewards
The total number of products sampled that offer rewards has remained relatively stable: only a few issuers added new rewards to their card products compared to the beginning of the year, primarily on credit cards, while the number of debit card products offering rewards decreased. The value of the rewards offered to cardholders, however, has decreased, particularly in markets where credit card interchange experienced steep declines. As noted in our prior article, many U.K. issuers decreased rewards dramatically prior to interchange regulations. In continental Europe, more issuers waited until after regulation took effective. For example, in the Czech Republic, where credit card interchange decreased 70-80 bps, Ceska Sporitelna announced that it has eliminated 1% cash back on credit card purchases except for e-commerce and foreign purchases, and Raiffeisen reduced the maximum monthly cash back reward on its premium card from CZK 1,000 to CZK 250. In markets such as Spain, where interchange has not been as steep, reductions are concentrated among the most generous programs Grupo Banco Popular, for example, has reduced the welcome miles for its Iberia Sendo rewards credit card program by approximately 20%.
European issuers have continued raising fees on other products and services. In France, Société Générale has increased the fee when consumers choose their own PIN. In the Czech Republic, Ceska Sporitelna has added additional fees for any transaction made at gambling and adult-services merchants, and also increased ATM cash withdrawal fees. KBC (Belgium), Banco Santander (Portugal) and Sydbank (Denmark) have also increased ATM cash withdrawal fees on some cards.
Issuers continue to adjust their product sets in light of interchange regulation. The timing and scale of mitigation has differed between issuers and countries, and we expect additional product modifications to occur in the near- to mid-term. This latest update to our research confirmed our previous hypotheses that European issuers will continue optimizing their rewards programs, and we expect this trend to continue in the short-term. In the longer term, we expect issuers to:
- Refine the user experience to clearly demonstrate the value of cards outside of rewards, and promote the ease of use and utility in e/m-commerce (e.g., easy checkout, spend tracking, easy access to credit and installments, etc.);
- Promote lending on cards, via both traditional methods (e.g., marketing revolving credit cards more) and digital commerce to promote installments on cards (e.g., BBVA’s mobile wallet has been successful in encouraging cardholders to select an installment option on traditional card platforms); and
- Build ways to monetize the vast amounts of data at issuers’ disposal, including using customer data more effectively to make offers to cardholders (both from the issuer and partners) that are more targeted and more integrated into the digital commerce experience.
For more information, please contact Elisabeth Magnor, Senior Analyst, email@example.com, specializing in Europe Initiatives.
To read the rest of this article, please subscribe to